Skip to content

SOI vs DOI conversion rate: what to compare

Novaxnetwork compares SOI vs DOI conversion rates by separating form submissions, confirmed signups, and approved payable leads. DOI adds a confirmation step after signup, creating another point where potential leads can drop out. Whether that makes an offer less profitable depends on payout, approvals, traffic costs, and the events being counted.

A higher signup rate does not always mean higher earnings. Comparing SOI and DOI requires looking at how many clicks become approved, payable leads and how much revenue those leads generate after traffic costs.

Start with the conversion event

SOI means single opt-in, without a separate confirmation action after submission. DOI means double opt-in, with an additional confirmation step, commonly through an email link.

The guide to SOI and DOI in affiliate marketing explains the signup flows. For performance analysis, the key question is which event your report calls a conversion: a submitted form, a confirmed contact, or an approved lead.

Different dashboards can use that word differently. Write the event definition beside every rate before comparing results.

Which conversion rate are you comparing?

Measure Calculation What it helps assess
Form submission rate Submissions ÷ clicks How effectively traffic reaches a completed form
DOI confirmation rate Confirmations ÷ submissions How many submitted signups complete confirmation
Approval rate after confirmation Approved leads ÷ confirmed signups Acceptance among confirmed contacts
Approved-lead conversion rate Approved leads ÷ clicks How much traffic produces payable leads
Approved EPC Approved commission revenue ÷ clicks Commission earned per referred click

Multiply the rate calculations by 100 to express them as percentages. EPC is a monetary amount rather than a percentage.

For SOI, approval is often assessed against submissions. For DOI, a report may show approval against confirmed signups. Those approval percentages have different denominators and should not be treated as equivalent quality scores.

Use the same click definition on both sides. Total clicks and unique clicks are different denominators. Also check whether repeat submissions, retries, and duplicate conversion notifications are removed consistently. Otherwise, a change in counting can resemble an improvement in the funnel even when visitor behavior has not changed.

SOI vs DOI conversion rate
Which conversion rate are you comparing?

Keep the comparison fair

Two separate offers may differ in audience, form length, payout, eligibility, and advertiser response. A comparison between them evaluates the complete commercial arrangements. It does not isolate the effect of adding confirmation.

If you want to test the opt-in method itself, agree on an authorized setup that holds other important conditions consistent. Where possible, assign eligible traffic concurrently rather than comparing one method this week with another during a different demand period.

Use sub-ID tracking in affiliate marketing to distinguish campaign versions and placements. Keep the reporting labels consistent so changes in traffic mix do not disappear inside an account-wide average.

Inspect comparable segments as well as the total. An account-wide rate can change because the share of mobile traffic, locations, or placements changes. That shift may happen even when performance within each segment is stable. Document the mix before attributing the change to SOI or DOI.

When combining placements, calculate the overall rate from summed counts. A placement with 10 clicks and another with 1,000 clicks should not have equal weight simply because both produced a percentage. Sum approved leads and divide by the relevant total clicks. Likewise, calculate overall EPC from total credited commission and clicks to avoid misleading averages.

A worked SOI vs DOI comparison

Consider two hypothetical offers, each receiving 1,000 tracked clicks at an advertising cost of $250. Assume each eligible signup is counted once.

These figures illustrate the calculations. They are not Novaxnetwork results, market benchmarks, or an earnings forecast.

Metric SOI offer DOI offer
Tracked clicks 1,000 1,000
Form submissions 150 140
Completed confirmations Not required 84
Approved payable leads 105 70
Payout per approved lead $3 $6
Approved commission revenue $315 $420
Approved-lead conversion rate 10.5% 7%
Approved EPC $0.315 $0.42
Revenue minus advertising spend $65 $170

SOI produces more approved leads, while DOI produces more approved commission under these assumptions. Both outcomes can be true because the payouts differ.

The advertising cost per approved lead is approximately $2.38 for SOI and $3.57 for DOI. The DOI lead costs more to acquire, but its larger commission leaves more revenue after advertising. Operating expenses still need to be deducted from both results.

Read each stage before drawing a conclusion

The DOI submission rate is 14%, its confirmation rate is 60%, and its approval rate among confirmed contacts is approximately 83.3%. Multiplying those conditional rates gives a 7% approved-lead conversion rate across clicks.

SOI approves 70% of its submitted forms. Comparing that 70% with DOI’s 83.3% would exclude the unconfirmed DOI signups from one side. The difference alone cannot establish which offer attracted better prospects.

Describe percentage changes carefully. Moving from a 10.5% approved rate to 7% is a decline of 3.5 percentage points. Relative to 10.5%, the decline is approximately one-third. Writing only “3.5% lower” would leave the size of the change unclear.

Calculate the confirmation rate needed to compete

Understanding how to calculate EPC and conversion rate lets you test whether an apparent payout advantage survives the funnel.

For a fixed-payout DOI offer:

Expected EPC = submission rate × confirmation rate × approval rate after confirmation × payout

Using the hypothetical DOI inputs, with confirmation rate represented by c:

Expected EPC = 0.14 × c × (70 ÷ 84) × $6 = $0.70 × c

To match the SOI offer’s $0.315 EPC, the modeled DOI confirmation rate would need to reach 45%, assuming the other inputs remain unchanged. Above that rate, modeled DOI revenue per click is higher; below it, it is lower.

This threshold compares the two offers. Advertising break-even is a different threshold, and both still need to cover operating expenses. Recalculate when payout, submission behavior, or approval performance changes.

At 40% confirmation, the same model produces $0.28 EPC. That exceeds the example’s $0.25 advertising cost per click, but falls below SOI’s $0.315 EPC. Covering advertising spend and outperforming the alternative are different tests. At 60% confirmation, modeled DOI EPC reaches $0.42.

The approval assumption matters just as much. If only half of confirmed contacts were approved, the modeled EPC at 60% confirmation would fall to $0.252. There would be almost no room above the example’s advertising cost, before other expenses. Track confirmation and acceptance together.

SOI vs DOI conversion rate
Calculate the confirmation rate needed to compete

Evaluate lead quality separately from confirmation

Confirmation shows that an additional signup action was completed. It does not automatically prove customer eligibility, buying intent, or future sales value.

Review the advertiser’s rejection reasons and the agreed qualification criteria. The process discussed as lead scrubbing in affiliate marketing can identify duplicates, incomplete information, or other ineligible submissions in either flow.

Where downstream feedback is available, examine contactability, qualified interest, and eventual customer outcomes. Keep those business-quality measures separate from the contractual rules determining which current leads earn commission.

A campaign can produce many valid contacts who rarely buy. Another can produce fewer contacts with stronger commercial interest. Confirmation rate alone does not describe that difference.

Allow results enough time to develop

A person may submit today, confirm tomorrow, and receive approval later. Group results by the original referral or signup period and follow them through subsequent stages.

Check the attribution window in affiliate marketing and ask how delayed confirmations receive credit. The time allowed for attribution and the time needed for approval are separate considerations.

Compare groups after a consistent observation period. A batch containing many recent pending signups cannot fairly be treated as final against an older batch whose validation has finished.

How to investigate a weak DOI conversion rate

Start with the stage that changed. If submissions fall, inspect audience fit, the offer promise, form usability, and technical errors. If submissions hold steady but confirmations fall, investigate the confirmation experience.

Mailchimp’s confirmation email troubleshooting guide identifies delivery delays, filtering, and signup-form problems as possible causes of missing confirmation messages. These are useful checks to discuss with the team that controls the process.

  • Set expectations: Explain that confirmation is required before the visitor submits.
  • Check message receipt: Use an authorized test to establish whether the expected message arrives.
  • Review recognition: Check whether the sender and purpose match the signup promise.
  • Verify completion: Confirm that the intended action leads to the correct recorded event.
  • Review acceptance: Investigate why completed confirmations do not become payable leads.

Work within the parts of the funnel you are authorized to manage. When the advertiser controls the form or confirmation message, provide stage counts and test evidence rather than assuming an ad change will solve the issue.

SOI vs DOI conversion rate
How to investigate a weak DOI conversion rate

When is a test ready for a spending decision?

Define the decision before the test: improve approved EPC, reduce acquisition cost, or increase contribution after advertising. Record the permitted traffic, audience, event definitions, and observation period.

A handful of conversions can produce unstable rates. The evidence needed depends on the baseline performance, the size of the difference, and how much uncertainty you can accept. A fixed click count does not guarantee a reliable winner.

For example, three approved conversions from 100 clicks produce a 3% rate; four produce 4%. The second percentage looks substantially larger, but one extra conversion separates the counts. Treat small differences in early samples cautiously and consider uncertainty before labeling a winner.

Before increasing spend, check that enough results have matured, tracking is working, and the apparent improvement is not explained by a different placement or eligibility mix. Keep the test budget and advertiser capacity in view.

Review incremental results as spending grows. Additional placements can bring different prices and intent, so the average from the original test may not describe the next group of clicks. Keep recording approved revenue and costs for each expansion rather than applying the original rate indefinitely.

SOI vs DOI conversion rate
When is a test ready for a spending decision?

Frequently asked questions about SOI vs DOI conversion rates

Does SOI always convert better than DOI?

No. DOI adds a confirmation stage, but submission rates, approvals, and traffic quality can differ between offers. Specify which conversion event you mean and compare equivalent reporting stages.

What is a good DOI confirmation rate?

There is no universal target that determines profitability. Calculate the rate your payout, traffic costs, and approval performance require, then compare it with mature results from your campaign.

Should I choose the offer with the highest conversion rate?

Compare approved commission revenue and costs as well. An offer generating fewer payable leads can still earn more per click if its payout compensates for the lower approved conversion rate.

Can email delivery problems affect the comparison?

Yes. If confirmation is required, a delayed or missing message can affect completion. Check receipt and recording before interpreting low confirmations as a lack of audience interest.